Sports 1958’s ‘Greatest Game Ever Played’ between Colts and Giants named best game in NFL history October 4, 2019Jace Evans, USA TODAYComments Off on 1958’s ‘Greatest Game Ever Played’ between Colts and Giants named best game in NFL history The 1958 NFL Championship Game, which was nicknamed "The Greatest Game Ever Played," was somewhat predictably named the best contest in NFL history.